Is it cheaper to convert a garage or to build an addition?

Are you looking to add more space to your home but unsure whether to convert your garage or build an addition? Both options have their pros and cons, and the best choice for you depends on several factors, including cost, time, resale value, and regulatory considerations. In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore these aspects in detail to help you make an informed decision.

Pros and Cons of Garage Conversions

Cost

Converting a garage is generally cheaper than building a new addition. The structure is already in place, reducing the need for extensive construction work. The average cost of converting a garage ranges from $6,000 to $19,000, depending on the extent of the renovation and the quality of materials used.

Time

Garage conversions are typically quicker to complete than building additions. You can expect the project to take between a few weeks to a few months, depending on the complexity.

Potential Resale Value

A well-executed garage conversion can increase your home's resale value. However, this largely depends on the quality of the conversion and the local real estate market. In some cases, losing garage space could be a downside for potential buyers.

Cons

• Loss of Storage: One significant drawback is the loss of storage or parking space for your vehicles.
• Limited Space: The size of your new living area will be restricted by the existing garage dimensions.
• Zoning Issues: You may face zoning restrictions that limit how you can convert your garage.

Pros and Cons of Building Additions

Cost

Building an addition is generally more expensive, with costs ranging from $20,000 to $60,000 or more, depending on the size and complexity. This includes the cost of foundations, roofing, and other structural elements.

Time

Building an addition takes longer than converting a garage. The project could last several months, depending on the scope of work and weather conditions.

Potential Resale Value

Adding square footage to your home typically increases its resale value more significantly than a garage conversion. Buyers often view additional living space as a premium feature.

Cons

• Higher Initial Costs: The upfront cost is significantly higher compared to a garage conversion.
• Longer Construction Time: Expect the project to take longer, which could be inconvenient if you're living in the home during construction.
• Regulatory Hurdles: Building an addition often requires more permits and adherence to stricter building codes.

Schedule a free call with our ADU experts

Case Studies and Examples

Real-Life Examples

1. Garage Conversion Case Study

• The place: San Francisco, CA
• Project Details: Converted a single-car garage into a home office and guest room.
• Outcome: Completed in two months at a cost of $65,000. Increased property value by approximately $75,000.

2. Building Addition Case Study

• The place: Portland, OR
• Project Details: Added a 400 sq. ft. family room to the back of the house.
• Outcome: Completed in six months at a cost of $75,000. Increased property value by approximately $90,000.

Financial Considerations

Initial Costs

• Garage Conversion: $6,000 to $19,000
• Building Addition: $20,000 to $60,000+

Potential Savings

Garage conversions offer immediate savings due to lower construction costs. Building additions, while more expensive initially, may provide a higher return on investment in the long run.

Long-Term Investment Value

Consider the long-term benefits of each option. A garage conversion is less costly upfront but offers limited additional space. An addition provides more space and potentially higher resale value but comes with higher initial costs and longer construction times.

Schedule a free call with our ADU experts

Regulatory and Practical Considerations

Zoning Laws and Building Codes

Before starting either project, check local zoning laws and building codes. These regulations can impact what you're allowed to do with your property. For example, some areas have strict rules about converting garages into living spaces.

Practical Implications

• Garage Conversion:
• Ensure the garage is properly insulated.
• Check for adequate ventilation and natural light.
• Consider the impact on parking and storage space.
• Building Addition:
• Assess the available space on your property.
• Consider the impact on your home's layout and exterior appearance.
• Plan for possible disruptions during the construction period.

Conclusion

Both garage conversions and building additions have their advantages and disadvantages. The best choice depends on your budget, the time you can commit to the project, and your long-term goals for your home. By carefully considering the cost, time, resale value, and regulatory aspects, you can make an informed decision that suits your needs.

Ready to take the next step? Schedule a free call with our ADU experts

‍